| Year | Male | Female | Coach |
| 2020 | |||
| 2019 | Sam Gilman | Meaghan Lyons | Jennifer Weitekamper |
| 2018 | Billy Christie | Mallory Liggett | Rawn Grant |
| 2017 | Bryce Singleton Ben Gilman | Da’Nesha Miller | Sean Rochester |
| 2016 | Martin Duane | Mariah Mervin | Garett Talarcyzk |
| 2015 | Jerome Maddox | Lilla Felix | Ernie Suozzi |
| 2014 | Poona Ford | Ciara McMahon | Wayne Quinlan |
| 2013 | Michael Julian | Faith Lifer | Ken Updike |
| 2012 | Alex MacDonald | Sabrina Drammis | Dave Greenberg |
| 2011 | Sara Manesiotis | Jack Felix | Bill Wrightson |
| 2010 | Nicole Menzel | Jack Duane | Bill Wrightson |
| 2009 | Emily Natoli | Greg Harrison | Bill Wrightson |
| 2008 | Lauren Kamperman | Cavin Sunkins | Nancy Clouse |
